Politics

December 10, 2006 12:25 AM

The vanity of Bush and Blair is the only reason we still have troops in Iraq

Iain Macwhirter

I THOUGHT it couldn't get worse, but it just has. The Iraq Study Group, far from showing a way out of the crisis, has become a new dimension of it. The wise men confirmed the war is unwinnable, but didn't...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

A decent man working in troubled times

Trevor Royle

So farewell then Kofi Annan. Later this week you'll make your last public pronouncement and then it will be time to start clearing your desk on the 38th floor of the UN building in New York, your embattled eyrie for...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

December 2, 2006 10:55 PM

Is the government above the law? It certainly hopes so

What we think

BEFORE CHRISTMAS, and possibly as early as next Friday, the prime minister of the government of the United Kingdom will be interviewed by police from Scotland Yard. The team headed by assistant commissioner John Yates is investigating whether or not...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

‘Special relationship’ is no great love affair

By Trevor Royle, Diplomatic Editor

BRITAIN'S SPECIAL relationship with the US is one of the oddities of the world of diplomacy. It's not a treaty and it's never been encapsulated by any formal agreement but, for good or ill, it does exist. Without it Britain...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

English nationalism, not Scottish, may decide the fate of the union

By Iain Macwhirter

JUST AS Scotland is beginning to tire of the latest flurry of nationalist speculation, based on a couple of rather optimistic opinion polls, England has rediscovered perfidious Caledonia. Last week, the London press was full of challenges to Scotland to...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

‘Labour stand to lose 12 of their 13 councils’

By Iain Macwhirter

YOU COULDN'T make it up. Our report today reveals that, according to YouGov, the Scottish Labour Party could be reduced to only one council after May 3: North Lanarkshire. It's fitting that the local authority that has become a by-word...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

November 25, 2006 11:50 PM

Why a new Trident can only make the world a more dangerous place

By Iain Macwhirter

YOU'LL HAVE had your debate. It took about an hour on Thursday for the decision to be taken by the UK Cabinet to replace Trident. The consultation will be an empty one, taking place over the Christmas holiday season, and...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

November 18, 2006 11:24 PM

Can David Cameron talk himself out of a beating and into No 10?

Iain Macwhirter on pugilism in politics

During the Queen’s speech last week, Tony Blair jeered: “However much you dance around the ring, at some point you’ll come within reach of a big clunking fist.” The “dancer” is, of course, the Tory leader David Cameron; the “clunker”,...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Fighting and common fear will keep our nation as one

Muriel Gray on the SNP’s ‘interesting’ policies

Don’t you hate it when artists use the word ‘interested’ when discussing their work? You know the sort of thing. Some sullen, unshaven creature will be filmed standing beside a melted plastic box topped by a toaster and a doll...

Read more » | Comments (10)

 

Expenses rules must change

What we think

Another week, another exposé of the parliament’s wretched Edinburgh Accommodation Allowance. Where John Home Robertson billed the public for renting from his son, and where transport minister Tavish Scott admitted to renting from his sister, the Sunday Herald has now...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Style, substance and France’s third way

Trevor Royle on Segolene Royal, the new socialist hope

It’s not easy being a woman in politics. For all that the glass ceiling has been broken by people as different as Golda Meir, Margaret Thatcher and Indira Gandhi, there’s still a suspicion in men’s minds that a politician wearing...

Read more » | Comments (3)

 

November 11, 2006 10:50 PM

Blair’s achievement in Iraq: making us the prime target for every jihadist

Iain Macwhirter on the cost of the war for Britain

Look, I too am opposed to the death penalty. But sometimes even I wonder if there should be an exception made; for Tony Blair. After all, there we were last week condemning Saddam Hussein for causing the deaths of tens,...

Read more » | Comments (1)

 

Drop the poppy posturing and remember those who gave their lives for us

Muriel Gray on a debate that demeans the war dead

Journalist Jon Snow’s refusal to wear a poppy while reading the news, his subsequent comment about “poppy fascism” and Christian calls to wear a white poppy instead of red to make a pacifist statement, all contributed this week to the...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

‘The very idea of poor me paying out £3500 a year’

Iain Macwhirter

Last week, as a result of disclosures in this paper, the Scottish parliament agreed to review the system of living allowances which has permitted MSPs to make large gains on the Edinburgh property market at the public’s expense. None of...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Lest we forget … the terrible cost of Blair’s legacy in Iraq

What we think

Remembrance Sunday no longer serves to commemorate only military triumphs of the past. Most of us, if we paused in silence for two minutes, gave thanks to parents and grandparents for their part in events which, although we know them...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Our attitude to leaders’ wives is bizarre, but can Middle America show us the way?

Ian Bell

SOUTH Dakota is a conservative sort of place. It barely counts as a fly-over state for the sophisticates of America’s coasts, glancing down on the farmlands from 30,000 feet. Below, the descendents of west European immigrants have made little impact...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Indiscriminate, inaccurate and inexcusable

Trevor Royle on why cluster bombs should be banned

There are few more hallowed places on God’s Earth than the rolling chalk downlands of the Somme or the wooded expanse of the Ypres salient to the north. Within their acres, hundreds of thousands of young men fought and died...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

November 4, 2006 10:57 PM

With Saddam’s death the nightmare will continue … and worsen

What we think

An extended curfew on the streets of Baghdad and in other provinces throughout Iraq; a climate of increasing violence, the discovery of 83 bodies showing signs of torture and a promise to open the gates of hell if a death...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

It’s time for MPs to stop hiding in the corner – and come out fighting

Iain Macwhirter on the state of democracy

Do we live in a democracy? I only ask. Of course, we elect people to parliaments – three of them, if you include the Scottish and European parliaments. But what do our elected members do when they get there, apart...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Fiji’s fragile balance of power in crisis

Trevor Royle on a cold-war standoff of state and army

In most parts of the world, a military commander’s promise of support is as good a reason as any for a politician to start packing bags and booking flights to unknown destinations. It’s a sure sign that their jacket is...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

October 28, 2006 11:11 PM

If methadone approach isn’t working, why not change the policy?

What we think

STUDIES have shown that most drug users seek help with the aim of eventually beating their addiction. Yet new research has revealed that only 4% of heroin addicts in Scotland who were prescribed methadone managed to become drug free nearly...

Read more » | Comments (3)

 

October 21, 2006 11:17 PM

The UK and America cannot be trusted to handle withdrawal alone

What we think

You make a mistake and, so the story goes, you learn a lesson and move on. The US president John F Kennedy acknowledged he made a mistake in trying to invade Cuba in the Bay of Pigs fiasco. He later...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

‘We are in a new and disturbing atomic age’

HOLYROOD COMMENTARY: Iain Macwhirter

The authentication of North Korea’s nuclear test by the American authorities last week confirmed that we are in a new and disturbing atomic age. No longer is the use of nuclear weapons as a means of resolving international disputes made...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Lest we forget: an arresting case to hold leaders accountable

Iain Macwhirter on Britain and the US' struggle to find a retreat from Iraq

So that’s it then. We’re pulling out of Iraq within the next, ooh, 18 months or so, before we become a “provocation”. So said the prime minister last week, echoing the dramatic change of tone from the White House. Funny,...

Read more » | Comments (1)

 

October 14, 2006 11:43 PM

General’s brave words should be the signal for a planned withdrawal

What we think

THE government’s policy on Iraq has never been a transient creed. There has been, even prior to the invasion of 2003, a stated aim: to turn Iraq, post-Saddam, into a pro-West democratic state. Its objective, emanating from the White House...

Read more » | Comments (1)

 

‘The SNP seem to be on their way at last’

HOLYROOD COMMENTARY: Iain Macwhirter

WHO would have thought that the SNP would stage the most successful party conference of the season? Labour were at war with themselves, the Liberal Democrats shell-shocked ,and the Tories accident prone. The nationalists, by contrast, seemed united, confident, businesslike,...

Read more » | Comments (2)

 

Kim Jong-il isn’t the only delusional politician with nuclear weapons

Iain Macwhirter on a lack of rational thinking

YOU don’t have to be mad to work here but it helps. The British Cabinet, it seems, was riddled with mental distress throughout the course of the Iraq war. It wasn’t just Gordon Brown who had psychological flaws. Alastair Campbell,...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

October 1, 2006 12:25 AM

The SNP’s identity crisis

What we think

THE ongoing bitterness between Nation alist leader Alex Salmond and his former ally Michael Russell will surprise few in the SNP. Although Salmond trounced the one-time MSP to regain the leadership in 2005, he was unimpressed by many of Russell’s...

Read more » | Comments (2)

 

Smothering political debate will only serve to fuel direct action

What we think

Unconventional and non-parliamentary political action has seen a substantial growth in Britain during the nine years Tony Blair has been prime minister. The poll-tax demonstrations at the tail-end of the Thatcher years showed the potential of a frustrated electorate. And...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Russia and Georgia on the brink – again

Trevor Royle on why the spy claim reveals deeper divisions

The Georgians are the Irish of the Caucasus. They are proud, high-minded, independent, prone to take offence, and when in a scrap they generally give as good as they get. Most of the time they think of themselves as poets...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

September 30, 2006 11:43 PM

‘When the world warms up, we’ll need new maps’

Holyrood commentary: Iain Macwhirter

The Scottish parliament discovered climate change this week – or rather the denial of it. The Futures Forum had decided to invite one of the last of the climate-change sceptics, the Danish statistician Bjorn Lomborg, to address an invited audience...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Matters too important to be left to politicians

Guest Vocals: Bernard Crick

DO we not all want to be good citizens, and for others – especially the young – to be good too? Yet we seem less keen on being active citizens. Even the minimal activity of voting in official elections is...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Blair’s long handover puts Labour in purgatory, and Conservatives in heaven

Iain Macwhirter on why Labour is tearing itself apart

Talk about open goals. David Cameron has been handed the easiest job in politics this week in Bournemouth as he makes his first annual conference address to the Conservatives as their leader. All he needs to do is stand there,...

Read more » | Comments (2)

 

September 23, 2006 11:46 PM

Brown is only politician who can meet global challenges of our times

Iain Macwhirter on the green chancellor

WHAT a week. The government of California took leading car manufacturers to court for manufacturing polluting vehicles; Richard Branson said he would plough the proceeds of his various transport interests into renewable energy; we learned that the Arctic is melting...

Read more » | Comments (1)

 

September 16, 2006 11:53 PM

McConnell’s dreams for Trident could put Brown in the history books

Iain Macwhirter on a plan for peace in the middle east

FIRST Minister Jack McConnell can’t win. If he speaks about important moral issues like nuclear defence, he is attacked for getting above himself. If he avoids the issue, on the grounds that defence is not a responsibility of the Scottish...

Read more » | Comments (2)

 

Bush prepares for his toughest audience

Trevor Royle on a president at odds with the world

Every year, as late summer gives way to the deep red and gold of a New England fall, world leaders get the chance to spend a few days schmoozing in New York. The United Nations gets back to business this...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Parties need to get back in touch with real people

Tommy Shepherd

A vacuum exists in the Scottish political spectrum larger than at any time since 1975, and the collective efforts of Scotland's political parties, which between them can persuade barely half the population to vote, seem unlikely to fill it. In...

Read more » | Comments (2)

 

‘Independence is the only path for Scots Tories’

HOLYROOD COMMENTARY: Iain Macwhirter

In future, the Scottish Tories are going to have to learn to love homosexuals. Well, that’s surely the implication of the historic meeting between the Conservative Party chairman, Francis Maude, and the gay pressure group Stonewall on Friday. I wonder...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

September 9, 2006 11:54 PM

Independence is only the first step

Tommy Sheridan on the issues that must be confronted before Scotland is truly free

Scotland is a rich country. We are a nation rich in talent, rich in ideas, rich in resources, yet some of our citizens have a lower life expectancy than people in Iraq and the Gaza strip. We export energy, oil,...

Read more » | Comments (18)

 

‘No prime minister can for long survive a rancorous squabble with their next-door neighbour at No 11’

By Norman Tebbit, former tory party chairman and close ally of Margaret Thatcher

Observing the dying days of prime minister Blair is bound to bring back memories of Margaret Thatcher’s last days in Number 10. In 1987, she won her third great election victory, polling some 40,000 more votes than at her first...

Read more » | Comments (1)

 

Fond memories of a monster

Trevor Royle

IF you’re of a certain age, you’ll remember the little red book and those cute Mao button badges that were such useful fashion accessories for those of an agitprop tendency back in the seventies. Thirty years after Mao Zedong’s death,...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

September 6, 2006 4:06 PM

What the Scottish National Party will do for Scotland

Nicola Sturgeon outlines the benefits she believes independence would offer Caledonia

The best future for Scotland and the Scottish people is independence. Not even Mr McConnell believes all the scaremongering rubbish he has been spouting in the last few days. He's just following orders. Everybody else in the Labour Party is...

Read more » | Comments (5)

 

September 2, 2006 8:35 PM

Do opposition parties want to govern? No

Holyrood commentary: Iain Macwhirter on the failure of Scotland’s small parties

There’s only one question at the start of this crucial election campaign: have they got the bottle? Do Scottish opposition parties really want to be in government after the Holyrood elections in May?   I’m afraid that the short answer...

Read more » | Comments (5)

 

The dysfunctional family values that tell us it’s time to get rid of Tony

Muriel Gray on the crazy notion of foetal asbos

Does Blair think we’re all buttoned up the back? Nothing he utters any more seems to have the remotest connection to the welfare of the country. It’s as though while hunched over Cherie’s Prada calculator, working out how much...

Read more » | Comments (6)

 

Will we even care what happens in final chapter of Blair succession saga?

Iain Macwhirter on the PM’s maddening long goodbye

So, now we know. Tony Blair isn’t going, according to The Times on Friday. Oh yes he is, according to The Guardian on the same day. The PM has decided it would be destabilising to give a timetable for his...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Hezbollah-isation is the next logical step

Trevor Royle on the plight of the Palestinians struggling to survive in the Gaza Strip

Either by accident or design, while events in southern Lebanon were grabbing the headlines all over the world everyone seemed to forget the plight facing the Palestinians in Gaza. In the same period over 200 Palestinians, mostly civilians, were killed...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

Why does the media hector Kennedy about booze while pretending to care?

Ian Bell

By his own confession, Charles Kennedy drank too much, too often, while attempting to lead the Liberal Democrats. Neither aberration is, in fact, illegal. A handful of people in Kennedy’s party and the Westminster media knew that excess had become...

Read more » | Comments (2)

 

It's true: I was an eighties' Scottish nationalist

Writer, musician and optimist Pat Kane on the rise and rise of the independence movement

It sounds like something you'd read in an alternative universe, where the New Statesman replaces Heat as the commuter's browse of choice: but yes, I Was Once An Eighties' Scottish Nationalist. Actually, I'm still an Oughties' Scottish Nationalist, and for...

Read more » | Comments (13)

 

Campaign with ideas, not deep pockets

Shiona Baird argues for limits to be placed on political parties' spending on election campaigns

Public funding of political parties is not exactly a popular cause. Meanwhile private funding of political parties has led to the "cash for peerages" scandal, to policy u-turns made solely to benefit rich donors, and to political parties being seen...

Read more » | Comments (0)

 

0309QualityRedefined.jpg

Advertising

Subscribe to this blog's feed RSS Subscriptions

Site Information