Posting Tools

Related Reading

Heat: How to Stop the Planet Burning
By George Monbiot
(Allen Lane £9.75)

Monarchy: From the Middle Ages to Modernity
By David Starkey
(HarperPress £11.04)

Having It So Good: Britain in the Fifties
By Peter Hennessy
(Allen Lane £17.61)

September 2, 2006 8:34 PM

The dysfunctional family values that tell us it’s time to get rid of Tony

Muriel Gray on the crazy notion of foetal asbos

Does Blair think we’re all buttoned up the back? Nothing he utters any more seems to have the remotest connection to the welfare of the country. It’s as though while hunched over Cherie’s Prada calculator, working out how much the first American lecture tour will bring in following his departure, some civil servant rudely interrupts his dreams by tapping him on the shoulder and telling him it’s time he made a policy statement or people might forget he’s supposed to be in charge. It’s the only logical explanation for the continuing spectacle of Blair spouting policy that sounds as though he’s just made it up on the spot.

Take his latest policy statement, the first to be announced since his return from holiday, doubtless still completely baffled as to why he had to take his shoes off at Barbados airport and hand over the Irn-Bru. Tony tells us that it’s now possible to identify children who will be a potential threat to us all before they are born, and that state intervention at this early stage needs to become more forthcoming. If we don’t do this, he tells us, “there are children that are going to grow up in families that we know perfectly well are completely dysfunctional and the kids a few years down the line are going to be a menace to society”.

Oh help! Then in that case we must act quickly on the Blair children. What chance for those young ones brought up by an egomaniacal, lying, Bible- thumping father, jointly responsible for 100,000 dead in an illegal war, and a mother whose ruthless, venal ambition makes Lady Macbeth look like an apathetic slacker? We must intervene with all due haste before they all turn into the “menace to society” their father has so clearly become before them.

But Blair doesn’t mean the children of middle-class bad guys. They’re free to grow up under the influence of nasty, materialistic, self-centred, uncompassionate parents and potentially carry on the tradition of being a stealthy menace to society in the world of commerce, politics or anywhere else they care to wield their skewed values. He means the children of underclass bad guys. You see, the children of the middle class, by Blair’s implication, have free will and the capability of growing up to make alternative moral choices from those of their parents. Nobody expects Jeffrey Archer’s children to become criminals or Donald Rumsfeld’s children to turn out just like dad and grow fiery scales, horns and a tail. We give these young humans the benefit of the doubt – as we should all children – that despite their influences and upbringing they are still individuals and unique personalities who have the capacity to defy their lot in life and choose their own road. But the problematic poor, Blair would have us believe, do not have any among their number gifted with this strength of character.

Listen to this from Blair, and see if it doesn’t chill your blood.

“If you’ve got someone who is a teenage mum, not married, not in a stable relationship, here is the support we are prepared to offer you, but we do need to keep a careful watch on you and how your situation is developing because all the indicators are that your type of situation can lead to problems in the future.”

Yikes! Not only are we back in that insidious and preposterous Thatcherite territory where all of society’s ill are pinned on young single women who have children out of wedlock, but you will notice there is considerably less compassion in that statement than threat. There is no suggestion that the single mother and her unborn offspring are themselves victims, but instead that they are merely grinning co-conspirators in making our safe, comfortable lives a misery. Take what meagre “support” we offer you, it says, or we’ll be on your case, keeping a “careful watch” on you. Because far from thinking that you might be carrying the next Robert Burns, Stephen Hawkins or Helena Kennedy, or even just a normal, gentle person, we know you’re going to give birth to nothing more than an irritant, a creature destined to steal BMWs, set fire to Mr Patel’s shop and burgle houses.

Let’s stop worrying about these scroungers and start worrying about ourselves for a change, all of us decent, hard-working people. Hooray for us. Boo to these young harlots and their criminal progeny. Blair clearly thinks he sounds tough when he spouts such garbage.

He thinks the Daily Mail audience will sigh with relief that finally the antisocial thugs, who undoubtedly ruin communities, are finally about to be dealt with. In reality, he sounds stupid which, with the blindingly clever Gordon Brown in the wings, is yet another of his many errors.

The problems of criminality and antisocial behaviour among the deprived are hardly going to be relieved by labelling babies as future happy-slappers and keeping a beady state eye on their mothers, ready to pounce when the first chubby fist picks up an alphabet brick and smashes it down on teddy’s head. How many good, kind, clever, experienced people, from all kinds of agencies, both public and private, have sat Blair down and explained to the twit that those with nothing to look forward to, nothing to plan for, nothing to work towards, have nothing to lose by being lawless, feckless and feral, and how many times has he failed to act on this blindingly obvious truth?

It’s interesting to wonder if Blair ever really cared about the poor at all in the way he pretended to back in 1997? Given his indifference to the body count in Iraq it doesn’t seem very likely that he weeps much for the poverty-stricken. But a great many in his party do, and I genuinely, optimistically, and perhaps naively believe Gordon Brown still does. We need Brown in Number 10 with the utmost urgency. There’s only one thing worse than a corrupt prime minister and that’s a stupid corrupt prime minister.

Comments (6)

Well said; dont trust Brown though, I dont remeber him being on any anti war demonstration.

Very well said! If Downing Street has not been sent a complimentary copy of the article, please do so!

Very well said!! Please send a complimentary copy to No 10 immediately!!

It's a bit like the paranoid middle class parent who hates their precious progeny spending time with kids that are a bad influence (in many cases this just means that they don't speak 'proper'), but, instead we're using this knee-jerk authoritarian, attempt to criminalise an entire class, this excuse for real leadership as a basis for policy. Incredible.

I sometimes wonder if the man is actually doing all this for a bet 'George, look what I got away with this time'! "Yeah pardner, I'm gonna invade Iran next. Those saps will believe ANYTHING ha ha ha...".

Anyway, seeing as are allowed to get all authoritarian now, how about we decide what's right for poor Tone for a change (seeing as he clearly hasn't got a bleeding clue) and stop him associating with people who are a bad influence on him? "Right, that's it Tony, I told you not to go to Dubya's place again, its no more dodgy loans and playing at Soldiers for you until you learn your lesson". It's for your own good you know....

Sad that this article chooses to approach a serious issue by using the sort of personal attacks on Cherie Blair that the almost mythical Daily Mail come out with.

Regarding what the Prime Minister has said, I do wonder whether it is the place of the state to start monitoring people of different personal circumstances to the norm (whatever that is) to ensure they behave as the state would wish. I think that the best way to deal with the problem of single-mothers in potentially vulnerable situations would be to have a effective post-natal care on the NHS, health visitors, trained counsellors, nurses etc who could give advice and support, especially if a mother doesn't have family around to rely on.

Too many people in Scotland have misplaced faith that Gordon Brown will be our saviour when Tony moves on to his higher destiny: he's backed every thing that Blair has done. He has been a main player in project "New Labour", and my guess is that he'll lead this country further down this same disasterous road.

Post a comment

I have read and accept the Terms & Conditions

0309QualityRedefined.jpg

Advertising

Technorati

Technorati search

Site Information